Last Friday, as I was preparing for a friend’s birthday party, the word came down from on high that Obama’s Department of Justice had filed a brief in the case of Smelt v. the United States. The brief cites a number of cases in which states determine independently of any federal law who can marry within their borders. I won’t recite the brief or the particular criticisms of it. Plenty of people have blogged about it, from Pam’s Houseblend (terrific) and New York Law School professor Arthur Leonard on Leonard Link (getting there, maybe). Even the New York Times thought the brief was a slap in the face to the GLBT community. Pam also makes the point in one of her entries that progressive straight people are not getting it, and are getting in the way with their defense of Obama. What I want to point out is something from Goldhagen’s thesis that I believe applies to the current situation of GLBT people in America: the history of gay-hating is so long and deep in America, that despite trends which may suggest the country is getting over it, the pernicious hatred of the GLBT community continues and is at a boiling point. Think Weimar Republic. Looks promising, and then…
Many people in America are commenting on the rise of hate groups, but they point toward the recent actions against Dr. Tiller in Kansas or the shooting of the guard at the Holocaust Museum. These are indeed acts of terror and hate. I don’t want to dismiss them. But it is important that we do not assume hate always manifests in a shooting. It comes upon us more subtly.
It came upon us on January 20, 2009 when Obama chose to have a gay-hater deliver his invocation, and he laughed at us. It came upon us when in Congress Virginia Fox said Matthew Shepard’s death was not a hate crime but a hoax. It comes with every soldier dismissed for being gay or lesbian. It stands out in the 26 states that have constitutional amendments banning gay marriage. It is there every time a census worker erases a gay marriage. It is present in the media attention given to Carrie Prejean, Miss California, whose beliefs are not only exactly the same as President Obama’s, but whose visibility is nearly as great.
For every court victory GLBT people win, more hatred starts to simmer. With every state that allows marriage equality, the hate becomes more palpable, as groups like the Knights of Columbus or the National Organization for Marriage (NOM) throw precious dollars at ad campaigns that feed, cloth, house, or ease the suffering of no one. As young people who taunted at school for being gay kill themselves, it grows less necessary for hate groups to kill us. Some of these young people may not have been gay, but the perception is enough–and not just the perception that they are gay, but the perception that being gay is so awful it merits one’s own destruction.
So let’s get rid of this crazy Hope’n'Change™ denial about what is really going on. There is a gay-hater in the White House. We don’t need to explore whether he hates gays because it is politically expedient or because deep down he has issues. It doesn’t matter. His actions matter. His words matter too, of course. Many people point to his explicit promises for gay civil rights and say, be patient. But let’s remember that to argue against gay marriage, he invoked his Christian faith, as if somehow being gay is anathema to all Christians, or that no Christians could support gay marriage. That’s insidious, and powerful.
Germany was one of the most cultured nations in the world when Hitler became its chancellor. It had begun to create equality for Jews; increasing numbers were given posts at universities. Many Jews identified at nationalistic Germans. One of them was Edith Stein, and she yet she tried in vain to warn others about what was happening in Germany. There were many people in denial about how powerful the forces were that were gathering in Germany.
I know that people will read this post and dismiss it as conspiracy theorist or hysterical. To them, I have nothing to say, except feel free to tell me I am wrong or misguided. I welcome all opinions here.
I am someone who believes in vigilance. And right now, when we can be dazzled by gay weddings, we also need to remember the gay cabarets that made the Weimar Republic seem like a safe haven. We have economic conditions that are becoming more stark. We have a long history of gay hate in the US. And we have a president who will apparently, like water, find the path of least resistance.
[This post is entitled Part II because after the election I wrote a piece by the same name.]
